Smart Toilet vs. Regular Toilet: Which One Should You Choose for Your Home?
- Local R&P
- 10 hours ago
- 5 min read
When planning a bathroom renovation or replacing an old toilet, you’ll face an important decision — should you stick with a regular toilet or upgrade to a smart toilet?
In recent years, smart toilets have gained popularity in modern homes due to their advanced features, water-saving technology, and comfort upgrades. But are they worth the extra cost compared to traditional models?
In this guide, our plumbing experts at Local Rooter Corp will walk you through everything you need to know about smart toilets vs. regular toilets — including how they work, the pros and cons of each, costs, and what type might be best for your home.
What Is a Smart Toilet?
A smart toilet is a technologically advanced toilet equipped with built-in features that improve comfort, hygiene, and efficiency. These toilets are commonly found in luxury hotels and modern homes, and brands like TOTO, Kohler, and American Standard have made them more accessible to homeowners.
Common Smart Toilet Features Include:
Automatic lid opening and closing
Heated toilet seat
Built-in bidet and warm air dryer
Touchless or remote flushing
Deodorizing system
Self-cleaning bowl and wand
LED night light
Leak or overflow detection
Water-saving dual-flush system
In short, a smart toilet combines comfort, convenience, and eco-efficiency in one unit.
What Is a Regular Toilet?
A regular toilet (also called a standard or manual toilet) is the classic model most homes still use. It operates mechanically with a handle or button to flush. While it lacks high-tech features, a regular toilet remains reliable, simple, and affordable.
Common Regular Toilet Types:
Gravity-fed toilet: Uses gravity and water pressure for flushing.
Pressure-assisted toilet: Adds air pressure for a stronger flush.
One-piece or two-piece design: Depending on your style preference and budget.
Dual-flush models: Offer “half” or “full” flush options to save water.
Smart Toilet vs. Regular Toilet: A Side-by-Side Comparison
Feature | Smart Toilet | Regular Toilet |
Comfort | Heated seats, bidet, automatic lid | Standard seat, no automation |
Hygiene | Touchless flush, self-cleaning | Manual flush, basic cleaning |
Water Efficiency | Dual-flush, sensor-based | Dual-flush optional |
Installation Cost | Higher (electrical + plumbing) | Lower (basic plumbing) |
Maintenance | More complex electronics | Easy and inexpensive |
Aesthetics | Sleek, modern design | Traditional and simple |
Price Range | $1,000–$6,000+ | $150–$600 |
Technology | Advanced smart features | Mechanical only |
Pros and Cons of a Smart Toilet
Pros:
Superior Hygiene
With hands-free operation, automatic flushing, and built-in bidet functions, smart toilets provide unmatched cleanliness.
Self-cleaning features reduce bacteria and odor buildup.
Comfort and Luxury
Heated seats, adjustable water temperature, and air drying bring spa-level comfort to your home.
Some models even include foot warmers or music functions.
Water Efficiency
Most smart toilets use advanced sensors to determine the flush volume, saving thousands of gallons of water annually.
Dual-flush options further minimize water waste.
Accessibility
Ideal for seniors or people with mobility challenges — the hands-free operation and seat height adjustments make it easier to use.
Smart Home Integration
High-end models can connect to Alexa or Google Assistant, track water usage, and send alerts for leaks or malfunctions.
Cons:
High Initial Cost
Smart toilets can cost anywhere from $1,000 to over $6,000, depending on brand and features.
Requires Electrical Connection
You’ll need an electrical outlet near the toilet, which may require an electrician to install.
Complex Repairs
If a smart feature fails, you might need specialized repair service or replacement parts.
Learning Curve
Some users find the controls (especially remote bidet functions) confusing at first.
Pros and Cons of a Regular Toilet
Pros:
Affordable
Regular toilets are inexpensive — most models cost between $150–$600, including installation.
Easy to Maintain
Simple mechanical design means fewer parts to break or replace.
Reliable and Durable
Tried-and-true design that lasts 10–15 years with minimal maintenance.
Widespread Compatibility
Works in any bathroom without electrical or plumbing modifications.
Water-Saving Options Available
Dual-flush and low-flow models can still help conserve water without added tech.
Cons:
Less Hygienic
Manual flushing and cleaning mean more contact with germs.
Limited Comfort
No heated seat or bidet — basic function only.
Outdated Appearance
Lacks the sleek, modern look of smart toilets.
Not Energy-Efficient
Older models often use 3–5 gallons per flush, wasting water and increasing bills.
Cost Comparison: Smart vs. Regular Toilet Installation
Smart Toilet Installation
Unit cost: $1,000–$6,000+
Installation cost: $400–$1,000 (depends on plumbing + electrical)
Total: $1,400–$7,000+
Regular Toilet Installation
Unit cost: $150–$600
Installation cost: $200–$400
Total: $350–$1,000
At Local Rooter Corp, our licensed plumbers install both smart and traditional toilets throughout San Jose, Los Gatos, Milpitas, and the Bay Area. We ensure the installation meets code requirements — including electrical setup for smart toilets and water efficiency compliance.
📞 Call us at (408) 868-8759 for a free toilet installation estimate.
Which One Saves More Water?
Water conservation is one of the top reasons homeowners upgrade their toilets.
Regular Toilets:
Older models (before 1994) use 3.5–5 gallons per flush (GPF).
Modern low-flow toilets use 1.28 GPF or less.
Smart Toilets:
Typically use 0.6–1.1 GPF depending on the flush cycle.
Some use smart sensors that adjust the flush volume automatically.
Over time, that difference can save over 2,000 gallons of water per person per year — lowering both your utility bill and environmental footprint.
Aesthetics and Design
Smart Toilets:
Sleek, one-piece designs with hidden plumbing lines.
Minimalist styles that enhance luxury bathrooms.
Wall-mounted options create a clean, floating appearance.
Regular Toilets:
More traditional look with visible tank and plumbing.
Available in multiple colors and sizes to match existing decor.
Two-piece designs are easier to transport and replace.
If you’re remodeling your bathroom, a smart toilet can elevate the overall aesthetic and even increase home resale value.
Maintenance and Longevity
Smart Toilets:
Require occasional sensor cleaning and software checks.
Self-cleaning nozzles reduce manual scrubbing.
May need professional servicing for electronic components.
Regular Toilets:
Basic maintenance — occasional flapper or fill valve replacement.
Easier DIY repairs.
No electrical concerns.
If simplicity and long-term reliability are priorities, a high-quality regular toilet remains a great choice.
Who Should Choose a Smart Toilet?
Smart toilets are ideal for homeowners who value:
Comfort and convenience
Modern bathroom design
Water and energy efficiency
Accessibility for seniors or those with limited mobility
Smart home integration
They’re also a strong investment for luxury homes, remodels, or master bathrooms.
Who Should Choose a Regular Toilet?
A standard toilet is best for homeowners who:
Want a budget-friendly option
Prefer simple, no-frills functionality
Rent out properties or manage commercial spaces
Want easy maintenance and repairs
For guest bathrooms or rental units, a reliable standard toilet often makes more financial sense.
Can a Plumber Install a Smart Toilet?
Yes — but it’s important to hire an experienced licensed plumber who understands both plumbing and electrical requirements.
At Local Rooter Corp, our team installs smart toilets from all major brands including TOTO, Kohler, and American Standard. We ensure proper:
Electrical outlet placement
Secure water line connections
Leak testing and calibration
Safe setup of bidet and automatic features
We also offer regular maintenance, water heater service, and complete plumbing system upgrades.
Final Verdict: Smart Toilet vs. Regular Toilet
Category | Winner |
Hygiene | Smart Toilet |
Comfort | Smart Toilet |
Affordability | Regular Toilet |
Ease of Maintenance | Regular Toilet |
Water Efficiency | Smart Toilet |
Installation Simplicity | Regular Toilet |
If your goal is luxury, cleanliness, and efficiency, a smart toilet is well worth the investment.If you’re on a budget or prefer simplicity, a regular toilet remains a dependable, cost-effective choice.
Upgrade Your Bathroom with Local Rooter Corp
Whether you’re ready to install a new smart toilet or simply replace an old regular model, Local Rooter Corp can help.We provide professional toilet installation, maintenance, and plumbing upgrades across the San Jose and Bay Area.
📞 Call (408) 868-8759 today to schedule a consultation or request a quote.Let’s help you choose the perfect toilet that fits your lifestyle, budget, and comfort.
Comments